Articles · Design
The best ecommerce website design is boring
Published
This is not a gallery of fifty stores we had nothing to do with. It is five of our own, with the reasoning behind each decision, because that is the only part of this subject an agency can actually add.
Best ecommerce web design is a phrase that usually returns a wall of screenshots with nothing said about whether any of them sell. The test applied below is conversion and speed on a phone, because a store that wins a design award and loads in four seconds has lost.
The honest caveat
Every article ranking for best ecommerce website design is a gallery of screenshots, and almost none of them tell you why anything on the page is the way it is. That is because the authors do not know: posting a picture of somebody else's store requires no knowledge of the constraints it was built under.
So the sample here is ours, and you should discount it accordingly. What we can offer that a gallery cannot is the decision behind each one, and what it cost.
What actually separates them
The stores that work are usually the ones that look least impressive in a screenshot. Good ecommerce web design is mostly a series of small refusals: not adding the carousel, not making the buyer scroll past a brand video to reach the products, not hiding the delivery cost until the last step.
Three things separate the genuinely good from the merely attractive. The collection page is designed, rather than being whatever grid the theme shipped with, which is where people actually shop. The product page answers the objection that stops this particular category from buying, which differs per catalogue and is the part templates cannot know. The awkward states exist: out of stock, empty search, one item in the basket, a variant combination nobody anticipated.
Five of our own, and why
Each of these is live and linked from our portfolio. What follows is the design decision worth explaining, not a summary of the project. If you searched shopify website examples, shopify websites examples or shopify store examples expecting a gallery of screenshots, this is closer to that than most pages claiming the term: real builds, live and linked, with the decision behind each one rather than a caption.
Cream Cornwall
Photography carries the store, and the interface gets out of its way.
Homewares sell on how the thing looks in a room you would want to live in. The design job was mostly restraint: large imagery, quiet typography, and no interface element competing with the product for attention.
WUKA
Absorbency and fit answered on the product page, before the buyer has to ask.
This is a category where the purchase depends on a question people are reluctant to ask a chatbot about. Design that surfaces the answer inline does more for conversion than any amount of visual polish.
Knack Snacks
The catalogue is organised by how people eat, not by how it is manufactured.
Food catalogues default to the internal taxonomy: flavour, format, pack size. Buyers think in occasions. Reorganising collections around that is a design decision that looks like an information-architecture one.
Black Sand
A gated trade store, designed for speed of reordering rather than for browsing.
A trade buyer placing a repeat order wants a fast path to a known SKU list. Almost every consumer-store design instinct is wrong here, which is why B2B stores built on consumer templates feel so laborious.
Skye McAlpine Tavola
Editorial pacing, with the shop woven through the content rather than bolted beside it.
When the brand is inseparable from the founder and the aesthetic is the product, splitting "content" from "shop" makes both weaker. The design has to let someone move between reading and buying without a change of scene.
What we would not copy
Including from the list above. The editorial pacing that suits a founder-led tableware brand would bury a catalogue of four hundred SKUs, and the restraint that lets homeware photography breathe reads as an unfinished store if the products are not shot to that standard.
This is the real problem with judging a top ecommerce website designs list: the entries are solutions to problems you cannot see. Copying the solution without the problem is how stores end up with a beautiful homepage and a collection page nobody can shop.
How to judge your own store
Four checks, none of which need a designer. Open your busiest collection page on a phone and count how many products you can see without scrolling. Find the question your customer service team answers most often and check whether the product page answers it. Search for something you do not sell and see what happens. Add one item to the basket and go all the way to payment.
Most stores fail at least two of those, and none of the four is a visual problem. If they turn up something, that is the work we do, and if the issues are behavioural rather than structural then testing them properly is the better first spend.
Common questions
- What makes the best ecommerce website design, as opposed to a nice-looking one?
- Whether it works on the pages nobody photographs. Anyone can make a homepage look good; the money is decided on collection pages with forty products, product pages with awkward variant combinations, and the empty-search and out-of-stock states that never appear in a portfolio. A store that is beautiful on the homepage and thoughtless at checkout is a worse design than a plain one that is careful all the way through.
- Should we copy the design of a store we admire?
- Copy the decisions, not the look. A layout that works for a fashion brand with six products and enormous photography will actively fail a catalogue of four hundred SKUs where people arrive knowing what they want. The useful question is what problem that store was solving, and whether you have the same problem.
- How much does good ecommerce design actually change sales?
- Enough to matter and less than design agencies imply, and anyone quoting you a percentage before seeing your store is guessing. What we can say without hand-waving: the biggest gains we see are almost never from making a store prettier, they come from removing a step, answering an objection earlier, or fixing something that was quietly broken on mobile.
- Is a template or a custom design better?
- A good template edited carefully beats a custom design done cheaply, most of the time. Custom earns its cost when the way you sell is genuinely unusual, when the catalogue has structure a template cannot express, or when the brand is the product. Otherwise you are paying for originality that customers do not notice and will inherit maintenance nobody warned you about.
- What is the most common ecommerce design mistake?
- Designing the homepage first and longest. Most sessions do not start there, and most revenue is not decided there. The collection page is where people actually shop and it is routinely the least-designed template on the store, handed over as whatever grid the theme shipped with.
Get in touch
Tell us about your store or your business and we'll reply personally. No wizard, no ten questions.
Stores we build and grow
